Blog

When you shop for jewelry, you’ll see endless listings for "real gold" or "14k–24k gold" priced under $100. They are everywhere, and they use the exact same luxury terminology as high-end, solid gold items. It’s incredibly easy to look at the two options side by side and think, “Is solid gold really worth the cost difference? What does it matter if they look identical? Who can tell?” 

You can. Or at least you will with time. To put it simply: for pieces you wear once or twice, unless you’re made of money, the gold plated pieces are really the only thing that makes sense. If, on the other hand, you’re a conscientious buyer only looking to add things you love or will wear daily to your collection the choice to get solid gold becomes the logical one. But I don’t want you to take my word alone or spend time experimenting with different manufacturing methods when you’d prefer to just experiment with your style. I have some pictures and thoughts I think will be really illuminating as you search for your next piece.

Types of Gold Manufacturing Methods: Quick Definitions

Before I outline the difference via pictures let me explain the different types of gold jewelry construction:

Gold Plated (or "Gold Dipped")

• The Process: A base metal (like brass, copper, or nickel) is submerged in a liquid solution containing gold. An electric current is passed through it, causing a microscopic layer of gold to bond to the surface.
• Gold Content: Virtually non-existent (typically less than 0.05% gold by weight). The layer is often less than 0.5 microns (1/1000nth of a millimeter or 1/25,000th of an inch) thick.
• Durability: Very low. Friction, water, perfume, and body oils will cause the gold layer to wear off rapidly, revealing the cheap base metal underneath.
• Best For: Fast-fashion trend pieces you only plan to wear occasionally for a single season. Expect it to last a year if you want to wear it often.

2. Gold Vermeil (pronounced ver-may)

• The Process: Gold vermeil is a premium version of gold plating that has a legal requirement on the amount of gold it contains. To be legally sold as “vermeil”, the base metal must be sterling silver
• Gold Content:  the gold layer must be at least 2.5 microns thick (5 times thicker than gold plated)
• Durability: Moderate. It lasts much longer than standard plating due to the thicker layer, but it will still eventually wear down with heavy, everyday use. However, because the base is sterling silver, it won't turn your skin green.
• Best For: High-quality statement pieces that you want to wear often but don't want to pay solid gold prices for; perfect for trying out a new style. For daily wear, expect it to last ~1 to 3 years.

3. Gold Filled

• The Process: Despite the name, gold-filled jewelry isn’t filled with gold. It is made by taking a thick sheet of solid gold and mechanically bonding it to a core of base metal (usually brass) using extreme heat and pressure.
• Gold Content: By law, the gold layer must equal to at least 5% of the item's total weight. This makes it up to 100 times thicker than standard gold plating and 2 to 40 times thicker than gold vermeil. 
• Durability: High. Because the gold layer is thick and mechanically fused, it resists tarnishing and chipping. With proper care, it can look beautiful for years.
• Best For: Everyday staple jewelry (like hoops or daily chains) if you are on a strict budget but want something that lasts. Expect 5-10 years out of a piece like this.
• Note: Although this is the closest to solid gold, it can be hard if not impossible to find a jeweler who can or will resize these pieces. 

4. Solid Gold

• The Process: There are no layers, shells, or cheap base metals here. The jewelry is made entirely of a gold alloy mixed consistently all the way through. Because 24k (pure) gold is too soft for daily wear, it is mixed with stronger metals like alloyed copper, silver, or zinc to create 10k, 14k, or 18k solid gold.
• Gold Content: Varies by karat (e.g., 10k is 41.7% pure gold, 14k is 58.3% pure gold, and 18k is 75% pure gold).
• Durability: The highest. It will never rub off, flake, change colours, or expose a mystery metal beneath. It can be worn in the shower, pool, and gym, and it maintains its intrinsic value forever.
• Best For: Lifetime investments, engagement rings, daily luxury staples, and heirloom pieces meant to be passed down.

The Lifecycle of Plated Gold: A Visual Timeline

Without further ado, take a look at these three chains:

The one in the middle is brand new and unworn. The one on the left I wore for 2 years before noticing it was hardly gold anymore. The chain on the right had only seen 7-9 months of wear. 

Some things to point out:

• I didn’t notice the change in colour easily

Because the colour loss is so gradual and I was wearing the necklace everyday, I didn’t realise how quickly it was losing its lustre. The eyes and brain work in tandem to help us perceive the world; I was expecting to see a gold chain, so my brain saw the chain as much more gold than it would’ve if I had seen the chain in that final state first. 

• They didn’t lose colour similarly

If you look at the 2 year chain versus the 9 month chain, you’ll notice that it’s a lot brighter. The 9 month chain is a deeper hue that the 2 year chain never experienced. These were purchased from the same vendor a year and some change apart so the fact that they wore differently is interesting but not atypical: because gold plating doesn’t have a template for the metal it is bonded to, you can’t guarantee how it wears and the tones it takes on as it does.

• I felt the change before I saw the change (particularly on the 9 month chain)

Part of the reason I bought the new chain was because I noticed the clasp felt a lot grungier and almost rusted than the 2 year chain. This forced me to really examine them side by side. In that time I had changed lotions and perfumes which, while being a fun side project in terms of self-exploration, are important variables when your skin is interacting with non-gold jewelry. Gold is inert (non-reactive) and thus great for being hypo-allergenic and lasting through the random things that come with life. The cheaper metal it’s bonded with? Not so much.

The True Cost: Breaking the Repurchasing Cycle 

Part of the reason I kept just rebuying was because (1) I wanted to give the artist her due and (2) Each purchase was only $55. I had convinced myself it was worth it to keep repurchasing on a per-wear basis assuming each purchase lasted a year. On the second necklace though I realised the first one only lasted as long as it did because I had purchased several necklace styles and was rotating them in and out to compare how I felt about each. The moment I went to everyday wear of that single necklace, it wore out quickly. The second purchase made this apparent.

Additionally, when the second necklace arrived I thought it was “too yellow” as the gold was deeper and more loud than I wanted. Because this was my second purchase, I knew some of the gold would wear off and it would become a tone I preferred quickly and it did: within 2 months I was at my preferred shade. However, within another 3 it had moved away from it. If I only counted the time it was a gold-tone I liked into the denominator of my cost-per-wear calculation, I was behind. At a year of wear of a single solid gold necklace I would have been even without including the residual value the metal alone holds.

Value isn’t only about cost. There is a moral value this repurchasing cycle didn’t align with as well: I don’t want to create waste. I want to buy something that lasts that I know can take a beating and wear it forever, not contribute to my guilt about the waste I’m generating. Even if the math worked out, I didn’t want to just throw something away because it wasn’t nice anymore. It just didn’t sit right with me. With solid gold pieces, I can get bigger, slimmer, change my routines and it can all come with me. I also save so much time not being distracted by all the other suggested items on the page every time I go to buy another. 

What I want you to take away

Your style is ever-evolving and something that is meant to be experimented with until you find exactly what suits you and that’s why I don’t think you should avoid cheaper gold pieces just because they aren’t ‘solid gold’. However, when you find a piece you love, I encourage you to look for it in solid gold because it will remain exactly the piece you love for a lifetime but also because it can grow and shrink with you. Here at Bayo’s Bobbles, I am committed to creating pieces you never want to take off which is why I focus exclusively on solid gold. I hope you’ll take a look at our offerings the next time you’re on the hunt for your new daily driver.